The Top 5 Best Popsicle Molds for Delicious Frozen Treats

is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

The 5 Best Popsicle Molds

If you want to save money and still enjoy the summer with a nice, cold treat, you should look into getting a set of the best popsicle molds. They are environmentally friendly, affordable, and can end up saving you money for years. Here are five of the best ice pop molds and a buying guide that you can follow to find the best popsicle mold for you.

The 5 Top Popsicle Molds

If you’ve been inspired by online videos showing fun and unique popsicle recipes and delicious homemade ice cream fresh out of the ice cream maker, you’ve probably gotten the itch to try them yourself or even make your own recipes. But what sort of popsicle molds should you buy? There’s many different varieties on the market, but we’ve narrowed it down to the five best popsicle molds to help you decide.

Editor’s PicksBrandRating *
Best ChoiceOzera Reusable Popsicle Molds Ice Pop Molds Maker♥♥♥♥♥
Premium PickOnyx Stainless Steel Popsicle Mold♥♥♥♥♥
Best ValuePopsicle Molds 4 Pieces Silicone Ice Pop Molds BPA Free♥♥♥♡♡
Best DisposableFrozip 125 Disposable Ice Popsicle Mold Bags♥♥♥♥♡
Best High-CapacityXmifer BBM01 Popsicle Molds Food Grade Silicone Frozen Ice Cream Maker♥♥♥♥♡
is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

* Ratings are determined using our specialized rating system.

Best Choice: Ozera Reusable Popsicle Molds Ice Pop Molds Maker

★ Best Choice
Best Choice for Best Popsicle Mold: Ozera Reusable Popsicle Molds Ice Pop Molds Maker

Ozera Reusable Popsicle Molds Ice Pop Molds Maker

The Ozera Reusable Popsicle Molds are our favorite choice for best popsicle molds because they’re sturdy, easy to use, and even come with a handy funnel and scrub brush for filling and cleaning.

The Ozera Reusable Popsicle Molds are a set of six clear plastic molds that fit into a base and can be removed as needed.They also come with a self-collapsing, silicone funnel and a small cleaning brush for manual cleaning, which is extremely convenient when dealing with small nooks and crannies. However, they’re also dishwasher safe so you don’t have to wash them by hand if you don’t want to.

These molds were made with kids and hot days in mind because the plastic sticks have a drip-catching design. I’m always a little hesitant when buying things online especially if I’m not familiar with the brand already, but this set of popsicle molds comes with a 100% money back guarantee. There’s no risk when trying these out because if you don’t love them, you can get your money back no matter what.

Item Key Features:

Pros

  • Easily affordable
  • Comes in a variety of fun colors
  • Comes with a funnel and cleaning brush
  • 100% money back guarantee

Cons

  • Not BPA-free

Premium Pick: Onyx Stainless Steel Popsicle Mold

♛ Premium Pick
Premium Pick for Best Popsicle Mold: Onyx Stainless Steel Popsicle Mold

Onyx Stainless Steel Popsicle Mold

The Onyx Stainless Steel Popsicle Molds are one of the best popsicle molds because of its sleek design and high quality materials, so these molds will be around for a long time.

The Onyx Stainless Steel Popsicle Molds stand out from other popsicle molds because they’re made from stainless steel instead of silicone. They require the use of real wooden popsicle sticks as the molds don’t have sticks built in, but each one does have a handy rubber stopper to keep the sticks from sliding in too far while freezing.

Because these molds are made from stainless steel, you can be confident when putting them in the dishwasher. Just make sure you remove the rubber popsicle stick stoppers beforehand, because they’re tiny and can get lost easily if they become dislodged. These popsicle molds will freeze popsicles in around seven hours, but could take longer or shorter depending on your freezer settings and recipe.

Item Key Features:

Pros

  • Long-lasting
  • Made from stainless steel
  • BPA-free and lead-free

Cons

  • Needs to be warmed to de-mold

Best Value: Popsicle Molds 4 Pieces Silicone Ice Pop Molds BPA Free

$ Best Value
Budget Choice for Best Popsicle Mold: Popsicle Molds 4 Pieces Silicone Ice Pop Molds BPA Free

Popsicle Molds 4 Pieces Silicone Ice Pop Molds BPA Free

The Amian Shop 4 Pieces Silicone Ice Pop Molds are one of the best popsicle molds if you don’t want to commit to a bunch of popsicles at once, and the easy-release molds make them simple to use.

The Amian Shop 4 Pieces Silicone Ice Pop Molds are great if you’re on a budget and don’t want to worry about an excess of extra pieces. Unlike the previous two molds, these have no removable parts aside from the sticks, and the molds are all in one piece, so there’s no risk of missing tiny pieces.

These molds are made of a food-grade silicone that is BPA free and FDA approved. While the mold only makes 4 popsicles per batch, it is still a similar size as the previous molds, so you aren’t missing out on your favorite summer treats. The silicone is durable, so you won’t have to worry about cracks and leaks, and they can even be turned inside out to make cleaning easier.

Pros

  • Easily affordable
  • Silicone is durable and won’t break easily
  • Safe and reliable
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee

Cons

  • Not dishwasher safe
  • Only makes four popsicles at once

Best Disposable: Frozip 125 Disposable Ice Popsicle Mold Bags

♥ Top Pick
Best Disposable for Best Popsicle Mold: Frozip 125 Disposable Ice Popsicle Mold Bags

Frozip 125 Disposable Ice Popsicle Mold Bags

The FroZip 125 Disposable Ice Popsicle Mold Bags are one of the best popsicle molds if you’re looking for something that puts function over form and makes transporting and freezing the popsicles a breeze.

The FroZip 125 Disposable Ice Popsicle Mold Bags make making popsicles as easy and also reduces the risk of spills as much as possible. If you have a cramped freezer that never has enough space for everything in it, let alone traditional popsicle molds, these bag molds have you covered. They don’t have to be facing a certain direction like normal molds. Just fill them, zip them closed, and toss them in the freezer for a few hours.

The biggest flaw with using baggies as popsicle molds is that they can sometimes pop or tear, be sure to treat them gently. However, what they lack in durability, they still make up for in overall convenience. These mold bags can be taken anywhere, and they even help cut down on mess because the popsicle never has to leave the bag while eating it. They even come with a collapsible silicone funnel, and the bags have a fill line clearly printed on them so you don’t overfill the molds and come back to a giant mess in your freezer.

Pros

  • Comes in a large pack of 125 bags
  • BPA-free
  • Can be used with juice, smoothies, yogurt and more

Cons

  • The bags can occasionally pop or leak
  • Product is not reusable

Best High-Capacity: Xmifer BBM01 Popsicle Molds Food Grade Silicone Frozen Ice Cream Maker

♥ Top Pick
Best High-Capacity for Best Popsicle Mold: Xmifer BBM01 Popsicle Molds Food Grade Silicone Frozen Ice Cream Maker

Xmifer BBM01 Popsicle Molds Food Grade Silicone Frozen Ice Cream Maker

The Xmifer BBM01 Popsicle molds are the best popsicle molds if you want to make a a lot of popsicles at one time, making it great for parties, big families, or people who just plain love popsicles.

The Xmifer BBM01 Popsicle Molds are a one-piece mold containing space to make up to ten popsicles at once. What separates this mold from the rest, other than the size, is the rubber lid that covers the entire mold that has stick holders, but it does not come with any popsicle sticks. Like many of the other molds, this one is BPA-free, which is great to see in anything that comes in contact with your food.

Because it is such a big mold, the center popsicles tend to take an extra 30 minutes or so compared to the ones at the end of the mold. Despite being a larger-sized mold, it can still be used with many different liquids like juice, yogurt, smoothie, and even applesauce. The silicone mold makes de-molding easy, so you won’t have to worry about accidentally destroying your treats.

Pros

  • Makes up to ten popsicles at once
  • Takes four to six hours to make a batch
  • BPA-free

Cons

  • Popsicles in the middle take longer to freeze

Important Popsicle Mold Features to Consider

There are a few different aspects of ice pop molds that can make or break them with every buyer. When buying your own molds, here are the most important things to consider.

Popsicle Mold Size

Popsicle molds most commonly come in sizes that make four to six popsicles at once. If you are just expecting to use them for yourself or one other person, you might be happy with the standard four-pack. Although, if you are like most of us out there who are never satisfied with just one at a time, especially on a hot day, or you have a large family, then you are probably better off looking for a six-pack or larger. The four- and six-packs are usually the easiest to find, but some molds can make eight or ten popsicles per batch but are sometimes smaller or thinner than the other sizes, so that’s another factor to consider.

Popsicle Mold Material

The two most popular materials that molds are made of are typically plastic or silicone, but metal molds are gaining popularity, too. There are some arguments over which materials are better, but make sure to always check any plastic or silicone molds before you buy them. Remember, the best popsicle molds are the ones that are BPA-free, which most are nowadays, but the cheaper quality ice pop molds may still contain BPA. When in doubt, check the internet for confirmation.

Popsicle Mold Freezing Time

two blackberry popsicles on a plate with fresh blackberries beside them All popsicles are going to take at least a few hours to freeze completely, but certain molds can affect the freezing time as well. Certain materials make it easier for cold to permeate the popsicle, which can speed up the process, and other can act as an insulator and slow the process down. Other factors to remember when considering freezing time is how cold the freezer is and the recipe you’re using. The more sugar in the popsicle, the more time it takes to freeze.

Disposable or Reusable Popsicle Molds?

The most popular argument is whether or not to use disposable or reusable popsicle molds. This can be a matter of preference, but realistically, it’s no secret that reusable ice pop molds are cheaper than regularly buying disposable, especially if you enjoy them on a regular basis Disposable molds may be the best popsicle mold option for you if you’re packing a kid’s lunch or having a picnic, so there are fewer things to keep track of. Whose kids haven’t lost their Tupperware and kitchen gear at least once?

Popsicle Mold Features

Popsicle molds all feature different design choices that make one stick out to you over others. For example, removable molds can be good if you’re looking for ones that are easier to clean. Handles can also be good for transporting the molds to and from the freezer, and drip catchers are great for enjoying your popsicles without having to worry about ruining your favorite shirt. Keep track of the features you like in popsicle molds, because they can be key to helping you find the one that’s best for you.

What to Know About Using Popsicle Molds

Even with these great suggestions, you may still be left wondering which one is the best for your needs. If this is so, here’s a handy buying guide you can use to help pick out the right molds so you get the features that are most important to you.

What are the Advantages of Popsicle Molds?

To name a few, using reusable popsicle molds is much cheaper than the buying packages of popsicles at the store. They are also environmentally friendly because they reduce the use of plastic, and they can lead to being healthier if you use juices with less sugar. In fact, many people use healthy replacements like yogurt, smoothie mix, fruit juice, and even applesauce as other substitutes, making a healthier treat without sacrificing taste.

How to Use Popsicle Molds

Fill the ice pop molds with your favorite juice, but leave empty space at the top so the popsicles can expand while freezing. Then, insert the stick and gently place it inside the freezer in a place where it won’t be bumped or moved. Wait for at least four to six hours (or better overnight) before gently trying to pull a stick out. If it comes out, reinsert it and let it freeze for another one or two hours. If it doesn’t, take the mold out, run it over cool or warm water for a few seconds and then gently pull the popsicle out.

Precautions for Using This Type of Product

Always make sure that the molds never contain any type of chemicals like BPA or phthalate by looking on the box, the instructions, or online reviews of the product. These chemicals are unsafe and can lead to certain health conditions. Also, check to confirm if the mold is dishwasher safe before attempting to put it in the dishwasher. Otherwise, it can lead to the mold or dishwasher getting damaged. The best popsicle molds should be BPA- and lead-free so your family can stay safe while using them.

Conclusion

four cherry and cream popsicles on a surface of ice surrounded by whole cherries If you still want a final recommendation, I don’t think you can go wrong with our top pick: the Ozera Reusable Popsicle Molds. They make six popsicles at once, which isn’t too many or too few for most people, and they aren’t much money, either. I love the drip guards built into the popsicle sticks because they’re just so handy, and I don’t have to worry as much about mess when I give my kids popsicles.

The funnel and cleaning brush are also extremely convenient. When making homemade popsicles, it’s very easy to spill when trying to get the mix into the molds, but the funnel makes that a thing of the past, and the scrub brush makes getting into those narrow spaces a breeze when it’s time to clean up. This is definitely the best popsicle mold for anyone wanting to easily enjoy popsicles made at home.

All in all, I love the Ozera Reusable Popsicle Molds, and I highly recommend them to all my friends who say they want to try making their own popsicles.