The Top 5 Best Ice Cream Containers

is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

The 5 Best Ice Cream Containers

Homemade ice cream is great to enjoy, but you need to find the best ice cream container in order to keep your ice cream fresh in the freezer. With several of the best reusable ice cream containers available to store everything you make in your ice cream maker, it can be tough finding the best ice cream container for your needs. The following ice cream container reviews and ratings can help you discover some of the best products available on the market today.

The 5 Top Ice Cream Containers

When searching for the best ice cream container, there are several factors to consider. Not only do you want a food storage option that will be safe, but you also want something convenient. After all, what is more frustrating that not being able to get delicious ice cream out of the container when you are hungry? Keep reading to discover our top 5 picks for the best ice cream containers.

Editor’s PicksBrandRating *
Best ChoiceStarPack Portion Control Mini Ice Cream Freezer Containers♥♥♥♥♥
Premium PickStarPack Long Scoop Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers♥♥♥♥♥
Best ValueEusoar 25pcs 12oz Ice Cream Freezer Containers with Lids♥♥♥♡♡
Runner UpBALCI Premium 1 Quart Ice Cream Containers 2 Pack♥♥♥♥♡
Honorable MentionMy Trendy Kitchen Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers♥♥♥♥♡
is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

* Ratings are determined using our specialized rating system.

★ Best Choice
Best Choice for Best Ice Cream Container: StarPack Portion Control Mini Ice Cream Freezer Containers

StarPack Portion Control Mini Ice Cream Freezer Containers are the best ice cream containers because they are made of high-quality materials and are microwave and dishwasher safe.

StarPack Portion Control Mini Ice Cream Freezer Containers come in a convenient 6-pack option—perfect for storing and freezing the ice cream you made from scratch. Each container is 6 oz., which makes this an excellent option for portion control. Divide up your favorite flavor of ice cream in convenient single-serve size options.

The 6-pack comes with 2 of each variety of colors, making color-coding ice cream flavors a breeze. Not only are these containers easily stackable, but they are made of high-quality materials. The plastic used on the containers is BPA free, and the material is both microwave and dishwasher safe.

Cleanup is a breeze with these best ice cream containers. Plus, what I really love about this product is that StarPack offers a full satisfaction guarantee, which means their products are 100% refundable if you are not completely happy with your purchase.

Pros

  • Easily stackable 6-pack
  • Both microwave and dishwasher safe
  • Made of high-quality, BPA-free material

Cons

  • Smaller size only holds about 3/4 cup
♛ Premium Pick
Premium Pick for Best Ice Cream Container: StarPack Long Scoop Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers

StarPack Long Scoop Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers are the best ice cream containers because their elongated shape makes them easy for scooping and storing. They also offer a PDF of cooking tips and a 100% money-back guarantee.

StarPack Long Scoop Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers are elongated ice cream containers perfect for storing homemade ice cream. This means they are perfectly sized to fit inside a freezer door, which is normally unused space. The elongated shape makes it easy to scoop out ice cream.

The materials on this product are safe and long-lasting, made of BPA-free plastic. These ice cream tubs are both microwave safe and dishwasher safe, making cleanup a breeze. StarPack stands by its products and offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee if you are not completely satisfied with this product. Plus, this product comes with a free PDF of cooking tips, so get your popsicle molds, whipped cream dispenser, and even your snow cone machine ready for your next endeavor in the kitchen.

Pros

  • Elongated shape makes scooping ice cream and freezer storage a breeze
  • BPA-free materials
  • 100% money-back guarantee

Cons

  • Only available in one color option, so color coding ice cream flavors would be difficult
$ Best Value
Budget Choice for Best Ice Cream Container: Eusoar 25pcs 12oz Ice Cream Freezer Containers with Lids

Eusoar 25pcs 12oz Ice Cream Freezer Containers with Lids are the best ice cream containers because they are easy to label, are disposable for easy sharing, and come in a pack of 25 for bulk storage.

Eusoar 25pcs 12oz Ice Cream Freezer Containers with Lids are the perfect storage tubs for keeping ice cream in the freezer. Each container is 12 oz and comes with a specially built lid. The lid has small holes in the bottom layer, which allows the ice cream to breath and can therefore prevent thermal expansion and leaking.

Made of top-quality materials, these ice cream containers are made with food-grade materials. Use these containers for one-time use options. They are perfect for sharing your homemade ice cream with family and friends. Eusoar 25pcs 12oz Ice Cream Freezer Containers with Lids are leak-proof and made with a textured exterior, meaning that the outside is easy to write or draw on, so it will be easy to label your ice cream flavors.

Pros

  • 25 containers make this an affordable option for bulk storage
  • Able to write on the exterior for convenient labeling
  • Disposable containers perfect for sharing

Cons

  • Non-reusable design can lead to waste
♥ Top Pick
Runner Up for Best Ice Cream Container: BALCI Premium 1 Quart Ice Cream Containers 2 Pack

BALCI Premium 1 Quart Ice Cream Containers 2 Pack are the best ice cream containers because they are refundable if you aren’t happy with the quality, the containers are dishwasher safe and BPA-free, and the lids are leak-proof.

BALCI Premium 1 Quart Ice Cream Containers 2 Pack are a perfect design for ice cream storage and are large enough to store up to one quart of ice cream in each container. Sold as a 2-pack, these ice cream containers are well-designed with a tight-fitting lid to prevent leaks. The lids are also designed to allow these ice cream containers to be stackable within the freezer. These containers are made with BPA-free plastic and are dishwasher safe.

Plus, there are a variety of color options available, so it is possible to color-code different ice cream flavors. What I really love about this product is that the company will replace or refund your product if you are not completely happy with the quality.

Pros

  • Made of quality material that is dishwasher safe and BPA-free
  • Stackable design helps to free up space in any mini freezer
  • Lids are designed to be leak-proof

Cons

  • Large container size does not make single-serving size an option
♥ Top Pick
Honorable Mention for Best Ice Cream Container: My Trendy Kitchen Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers

My Trendy Kitchen Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers are the best ice cream containers because the set includes different sized containers for different storage options. The containers can store more than just ice cream, and the containers are stackable to optimize freezer space.

If you are looking for value, My Trendy Kitchen Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers may be your best bet, whether you want to store ice cream, gelato, or sorbet. The set includes three 1-quart containers, as well as two additional serving size containers. You get five ice cream containers that are perfect for storing bulk ice cream as well as a single serving size.

The materials on this product are made of BPA-free plastic and are dishwasher safe. The containers are stackable, making them easy to store. While these containers were intended for ice cream, they can certainly be used to store any food item like frozen yogurt or another frozen dessert. These ice cream containers come with a 90-day money-back guarantee and a three-year warranty on the product itself.

Pros

  • Multiple size options allow bulk storage and single-serving options
  • Leak-proof lids with a tight seal

Cons

  • Only offers a 90-day money-back guarantee, which is rather short compared to alternative options

Features to Consider for the Best Ice Cream Container

Before selecting the best ice cream container for your needs, it is important to consider the different features possible in ice cream containers. Identify your own needs and plans for your ice cream before making your final selection. At a minimum, consider the following features commonly found in ice cream containers.

Size

Consider both the size of the container and the shape. The size will dictate how much ice cream you are able to store. Some people prefer to have a single-serving option, selecting multiple small containers, while other people prefer to have the ability to store up to a quart of ice cream at a time. Further, consider the overall shape of the ice cream container. Tall and slender containers can make it difficult to scoop out ice cream, while elongated containers might fit better into the door of the freezer. Lastly, make sure multiple containers are able to be stacked. This can reduce the amount of room they take up in the freezer and can make storage easier.

Reusable

One of the best features for an ice cream container is the ability to reuse the container. When searching for the best reusable ice cream container, consider how it will be used. If you plan to keep the ice cream container in your home, it is important to make sure the container is dishwasher safe. This will make cleanup and preparation much easier.

Materials

Consider that you will be eating the ice cream within the container. Because you will be ingesting the food, you want to make sure that your container is made with food-grade materials. If the container is made of plastic, check that it is made with BPA-free materials. These materials are safe for people to use and tend to not break down over time. Many of the best ice cream containers are able to be washed in the dishwasher.

With repeated washings, sub-par materials can have a tendency to break down. After repeated uses, parts of the containers can end up in your ice cream and food. With quality materials, you can ensure that your ice cream containers stay secure and intact.

Benefits of Using Ice Cream Containers

There is something special about homemade ice cream. Not only do you get to monitor the exact products, ingredients or ice cream cookbook recipes you are using, but you are able to create customized flavors and blends. Being able to store your homemade ice cream requires the best ice cream container. This allows you to wash and refill with ice cream each and every time a new batch is made. This option is less wasteful than disposable ice cream containers and helps save money in the long run.

By having the best ice cream container, you are also able to share your homemade ice cream with family and friends. Opt for a disposable option if you are planning to give the ice cream away. Not only will you be able to enjoy single-serving sizes of your custom flavors, but you can gift the ice cream to your friends and family too. Smaller ice cream containers allow you to make multiple different flavors and can also help with portion control, limiting the amount of ice cream to a single-serving size. These are usually stackable and take up minimal room in the freezer.

Precautions of Using Ice Cream Containers

When selecting the best ice cream container, it is important to choose the best option for your needs. While you want to be able to store your homemade ice cream, consider how much freezer space you have available and the quantity of ice cream you are willing to store. Many of the best ice cream containers only come in large sizes of a quart or more, which could make single servings difficult.

Furthermore, think about the type of materials that the best ice cream container is made of. You will be putting food in the container, so you want to ensure that the container is made from safe materials. Look for containers that are BPA-free or are made with food-grade materials. You will be using and washing these containers regularly, so you do not want sub-quality products degrading into your food over time.

Lastly, watch out for ice cream containers that do not have tight-fitting lids. Not only can a loose lid lead to leaks, but it can let in moisture. This can cause your ice cream to go bad quickly, and form ice crystals on the surface. A tight-fitting lid can be made of any material, but the best ice cream containers advertise a leak-proof construction.

Conclusion

When selecting the best ice cream container, there is one clear winner: The StarPack Portion Control Mini Ice Cream Freezer Containers. Not only are these containers stackable, but they are made in easy, single-serving sizes. With this package option, you will receive 6 small, single-serving containers. This best ice cream container is made of high-quality materials with BPA-free plastics. Further, the material is both microwave safe and dishwasher safe, making clean up easy. StarPack also backs its product with a 100% guarantee if you are not completely satisfied with this product.