Top 5 Best Gelato Makers

is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

The 5 Best Gelato Makers

Gelato is an Italian dessert invented in the 16th century, and when made by the best gelato maker, it is creamy and tasty. The delicious flavor melts in your mouth, and it’s easy to get addicted after your first taste. You will want to buy a gelato maker to create marvelous flavors of your own, like mint chocolate chip. Read our gelato maker reviews & ratings to find the best gelato maker today.

The 5 Top Gelato Makers

To make this tasty dessert, you want to buy the best gelato maker you can find. I took a look at popular gelato machines and their features to help you decide which one is the best gelato maker for your needs. Read my reviews to choose the best gelato maker.

Editor’s PicksBrandRating *
Best ChoiceCuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker♥♥♥♥♥
Premium PickLello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker♥♥♥♥♥
Best ValueKlarstein Dolce Bacio Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with Compression Cooling ♥♥♥♡♡
Runner UpWhynter 2.1-Quart Stainless Steel Ice Cream and Gelato Maker♥♥♥♥♡
Honorable MentionBreville Smart Scoop Automatic/Manual Electric Home Ice Cream and Gelato Maker♥♥♥♥♡
is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

* Ratings are determined using our specialized rating system.

Best Choice: Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

★ Best Choice
Best Choice for Best Gelato Maker: Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

The Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker is the best gelato maker because it is a quality appliance made from BPA-free materials. It includes a recipe book and the functions are automatic.

The Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker is a multi-purpose ice cream maker. I like how it can be used to make up to one and one-half quarts of either ice cream or gelato. Everything is automatic. Just change the ice cream paddle to the one that makes gelato, fill the machine with your favorite contents according to your tastes and set it to operate with the touch-pad controls. Then, the LCD readout will tell you when it is ready. There is a special extra ten-minute, keep-cool feature after the timer goes off.

This appliance is similar to a commercial ice cream maker one might find in the kitchen of a fine restaurant. Its brushed metal with a black exterior design is both attractive and useful. It is really easy for me to clean the ice cream machine by placing the parts in soapy water and then rinsing them off. I like the small footprint it has. It takes up little space and is a nice countertop ice cream maker.

Pros

  • Made from BPA-free materials
  • Includes recipe book for gelato, ice cream, and sorbet
  • Automatic, up to 60-minute timer with ten-minutes extra cool time
  • See-through lid

Cons

  • The mixing bowl is aluminum

Premium Pick: Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

♛ Premium Pick
Premium Pick for Best Gelato Maker: Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

The Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker is the best gelato machine because it is a compact size with a contemporary design. It also includes a recipe book and a one-year warranty.

The Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker is a compact machine measuring only 12 inches in width, 11 inches in height, and 18 inches in depth. It has a nice contemporary Italian design rendered in beautiful stainless steel. It is easy to use. The stainless steel parts are durable and easy to clean. It has an automatic two-button operation. Just fill it with the ingredients and press a button to start the process.

This choice for best gelato maker, also makes ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt, and frozen drinks. This unit operates immediately. It does not require a pre-freeze of the mixing bowl for hours before use like a freezer bowl ice cream maker. It can make a batch of one and one-half quarts in 30 minutes. It makes up to three quarts of gelato per hour with continuous use. It has a safety feature that causes the unit to shut off automatically if the churning becomes too hard for the motor to continue.

Pros

  • Stainless steel mixing bowl, paddle, and housing
  • Easy to clean
  • Includes a one-year warranty
  • Bonus recipe book

Cons

  • May take longer to make compared to other models

Best Value: Klarstein Dolce Bacio Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with Compression Cooling

$ Best Value
Budget Choice for Best Gelato Maker: Klarstein Dolce Bacio Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with Compression Cooling

Klarstein Dolce Bacio Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with Compression Cooling

The Klarstein Dolce Bacio Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with Compression Cooling is the best gelato maker because it makes larger batches than other models. It includes a FlavourMix feature to add ingredients during processing and comes with a one-year warranty.

The reason why the Klarstein Dolce Bacio Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with Compression Cooling is the best gelato maker choice for its price is that it makes bigger batches than the other models I reviewed. It is considered to be “family size” because it can make up to 67 fluid ounces as one batch, which is just slightly more than two quarts of ice cream. If you need to make big batches, this is the best choice. It is easy to use and clean.

It works well and can make a big batch within one hour. It also has a unique and clever feature, which is a small opening in the clear lid that can be used while it is operating to add mix-in ingredients for delectable frozen treats. Many recipes call for the addition of ingredients, such as nuts or cookie pieces, after the process has mixed and frozen the other ingredients. I love this idea because these additional ingredients can easily be added at the right moment to create the consistency and taste you want. With this unit, you can make homemade ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and frozen yogurt.

Pros

  • Makes large-size batches of creamy ice cream
  • FlavourMix opening to add ingredients during processing
  • One-hour extended cooling after the mixing process is done
  • Intuitive control panel with an LCD

Cons

  • Uses more electricity (180 watts) than smaller units

Runner Up: Whynter 2.1-Quart Stainless Steel Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

♥ Top Pick
Runner Up for Best Gelato Maker: Whynter 2.1-Quart Stainless Steel Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Whynter 2.1-Quart Stainless Steel Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

The Whynter Stainless Steel Ice Cream and Gelato Maker 2.1-Quart is the best gelato maker because it includes a safety feature to stop the unit from burning out if the mixture becomes too thick. It has a built-in timer and can make a variety of frozen desserts.

Of the group of the best gelato maker choices, the Whynter Stainless Steel Ice Cream and Gelato Maker 2.1-Quart is another large-batch style capable of making 2.1 quarts at once. The timer is built-in. It gives an audible signal when the process is done. It is suitable for continuous use and does not require pre-freezing the mixing bowl. It takes about one hour to make a batch. It can make gelato, ice cream, sorbet, and frozen yogurt. You can request a free book of special recipes from the company.

It has a safety feature to stop the unit and keep the motor from burning out if the mixture becomes too thick from freezing. It has a clear lid to make it easy to see the ingredients being mixed. The process makes a soft and creamy texture. If you want harder ice cream, you need to place the finished product in a refrigerator freezer for a couple more hours after it is made.

Pros

  • Compressor is highly efficient and CFC free
  • Extended cooling function after the mixing process is finished
  • Stainless steel exterior is attractive, durable, and easy to clean
  • Easy to use with a built-in timer

Cons

  • The mixing bowl is aluminum

Honorable Mention: Breville Smart Scoop Automatic/Manual Electric Home Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

♥ Top Pick
Honorable Mention for Best Gelato Maker: Breville Smart Scoop Automatic/Manual Electric Home Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Breville Smart Scoop Automatic/Manual Electric Home Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

The Breville Smart Scoop Automatic/Manual Electric Home Ice Cream and Gelato Maker is the best gelato maker because it has 12 different hardness settings for the ice cream. It has an LCD screen for easy use and will alert you when the process is complete.

A unique feature of the Breville Smart Scoop Automatic/Manual Electric Home Ice Cream and Gelato Maker model is the automatic hardness settings. Choose from the 12 different hardness settings to get the one you prefer. This unit will keep the product ready until you want to serve it for up to an additional three hours after the mixing process is finished. This is very helpful when making a homemade dessert to have it ready after serving a full meal.

This unit makes 1.5 quarts per batch. It can make gelato, ice cream, sorbet, and frozen yogurt. It has both manual and fully automatic functions. The controls are easy to use and the status is shown on an LCD. There is a convenient status bar to show the progress. It will show when it is the proper time to add the things you want to mix in. When the process is done, it will either beep or you can choose from three different musical tones.

Pros

  • Made from BPA-free materials
  • Includes a child lock
  • Easy to clean and use

Cons

  • This unit is noisy when operating

Features to Consider for the Best Gelato Maker

When looking for the best gelato maker, I think you will want to consider the capacity, paddles, durability, ease of use and cleaning, power consumption, and operating noise.

Capacity

The capacity range of a gelato maker I reviewed is from about one and a half quarts to just over two quarts. If you are making a dessert for one or two people, the smaller capacity is sufficient. However, if you have a large family who loves to eat gelato, or are planning an ice cream buffet, then it would be best to choose a larger-capacity unit.

Paddles

Different shapes for paddles can make it easier to create the types of desserts you would like to enjoy. Ice cream is harder and the paddles to make ice cream are stronger and work with thick cream. Paddles designed to introduce more air into the mixture make ice cream fluffy, which feels better. A paddle designed to make gelato works with milk instead of cream, which makes a denser mixture with less air.

Durability

I am partial to stainless steel for its attractiveness and strength. When the exterior of a gelato maker is made of stainless steel, it is easy to keep clean and shiny like new. Having a stainless steel mixing bowl is better than one made from aluminum because aluminum mixing bowls are easy to dent. Many do not like to use aluminum for any kind of food processing because of the chance of getting some aluminum metal into the food.

Ease of Use and Cleaning

The features to look for include having an automatic process using one button, the ability to select hardness settings, and having a small window in the lid to add mix-in ingredients at the proper moment. The settings to use the best gelato maker should be intuitive and the status on the LED display should be easy to read.

Check how easy the pieces are to separate and clean. The paddle should disconnect easily. The mixing bowl should be easy to remove. It is convenient if all the pieces are dishwasher safe.

Power Consumption

The units with higher power consumption make larger batches and work faster; however, they also use more electricity. Check the wattage to see how much power the unit will use. The same goes with old fashioned ice cream makers, ice cream ball, or any other type of electric ice cream maker.

Operating Noise

The one thing most people do not think about when choosing the best gelato maker is the noise the device makes when working.

Benefits of Using Gelato Makers

After tasting homemade gelato, you will probably be hooked. It is delicious when made fresh. The taste of the ingredients is amazing when using fresh fruit compared to buying something from the grocery store freezer.

It is nice to have the ability to make gelato instead of ice cream when you want it and in batches that can be enjoyed while fresh. It is also nice these devices make other frozen desserts too. If you want to make batches to save for future use, you can save money by making multiple batches and then freeze them.

Having the best gelato maker is a wonderful way to take advantage of low-cost fresh fruits when they are in season. Kids love to help with the process of making homemade gelato.

Precautions of Using Gelato Makers

The one complaint some people have when first using a gelato maker is the product is not hard enough. It is like the consistency of ice cream from a soft serve ice cream machine. For gelato, this may be the preferred texture; however, many expect ice cream to be harder. The way to get ice cream from a gelato maker to be firmer is to take the mixed product at the end of the process and put it in the refrigerator freezer for a couple of hours before eating it.

The operating noise is different between units with lower power requirements compared to units with higher power requirements. Check the operating noise before deciding.

Another consideration is if the product becomes frozen solid when mixing it, this can cause the motor to overheat and burn out. It is better if the unit has a safety feature that shuts off the power if the mixture is too hard. With this feature, the possibility of burning out a motor is avoided.

Conclusion

My top pick for the best gelato maker is the Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker. I like this device because of its style and the reliability of the brand. It is a good size for two people, which works well for me. The unique paddles included in this unit create a significant difference in the taste and texture of the product it makes. The gelato comes out perfectly every time. The ice cream is tasty and fluffy like soft ice cream with the texture I enjoy.

There is an exceptional book of recipes included with the unit. I have tried them all and even make ice cream from scratch now. I am very satisfied with my choice of the best gelato maker.